Holiday Gift Guide: What Grandchildren Really Want from Grandparents
Holiday gifts from grandparents often miss the mark, wasting money on toys that create safety hazards or clutter closets. This age-by-age guide shows you exactly what children really want—and how to avoid the common mistakes that frustrate parents.
Sylvia knew her granddaughter loved Paw Patrol, so she couldn't resist the Paw Patrol modeling clay set she saw at Target. She didn't realize it was made for older children and contained small parts that were a choking hazard. Her daughter-in-law thanked her, then returned it the next day. Sylvia felt embarrassed and frustrated—she'd spent $30 on something that missed the mark completely.
This scene plays out in countless homes every holiday season. Store displays, internet ads, and catalogs make it too tempting to buy gifts that look perfect—but don't match what children actually need or can safely use.
Understanding what children really want at different ages
The secret to successful holiday gift-giving isn't about spending more money or buying the trendiest toys. It's about understanding developmental stages and matching gifts to where children actually are right now. A toy that's perfect for a three-year-old might bore a five-year-old or frustrate a toddler. Parents know this from daily observation, but grandparents who see grandchildren less frequently might not notice these developmental shifts.
Toys that match a child's developmental stage tend to hold their interest better. This doesn't mean you need a child development degree to shop for gifts. It means checking in with parents before you buy, paying attention to what captivates your grandchild during visits, and choosing quality over quantity.
The age-by-age gift guide grandparents actually need
For babies under one year: Parents want gifts that support sensory development without overwhelming their baby. Think high-contrast board books, soft rattles with different textures, and simple stacking toys. Skip anything with small parts, batteries, or flashing lights. The goal at this age is simple sensory exploration, not entertainment. Babies don't need elaborate playsets—they need safe objects they can mouth, shake, and manipulate while building neural connections. See the best gifts for babies here.
For toddlers ages one to three: This age craves movement and imitation play. Push toys, simple puzzles with large pieces, and pretend play items like play food or toy phones tap into their developmental sweet spot. The simpler the better. Avoid toys with complicated instructions or multiple small pieces that create choking hazards. Toddlers want to do what the adults around them do, so gifts that let them "help" or "work" alongside caregivers often get the most use. We share the best gifts for toddlers.
For preschoolers ages three to five: Imagination explodes during these years. Dress-up clothes, building blocks, art supplies, and simple board games get heavy rotation. Skip educational tablets or screen-based gifts unless parents specifically request them. Most families have firm screen time rules at this age, and showing up with an electronic gift can create tension. Preschoolers need hands-on, open-ended toys that let them create their own play scenarios rather than following programmed sequences. We recommend the best gifts for preschoolers.
For school-age children five to ten: This age values collecting, creating, and mastering new skills. Craft kits, age-appropriate books, sports equipment, and hobby-related gifts hit the mark. Avoid gifts that require extensive parent involvement to set up or use unless you've confirmed parents have the bandwidth for that. School-age children are developing their own interests and identities, so a gift that connects to something they're already passionate about will always outperform a random "cool toy" you spotted. We’ve got recommendations for the best gifts for kids.
For preteens and teens: Experience gifts, gift cards to their favorite stores, books from popular series, and items related to their specific interests work best. Skip anything that feels like you're trying too hard to be "cool" or relevant. Teens can smell performative gift-giving from a mile away. At this age, respecting their autonomy and individual taste matters more than surprising them with something you think they should like. See our picks for the best gifts for teens.
The gifts parents really want you to skip
“One high-quality gift that matches a child’s developmental stage beats ten random items that clutter closets. Quality over quantity wins every time.”
Certain gift categories consistently frustrate parents, even when grandparents have the best intentions. Understanding why can help you avoid these pitfalls. Parents want to avoid gifts that create extra work, safety concerns, or family conflict. That beautiful drum set might seem like a fun gift to you, but to parents living in an apartment, it's a noise nightmare. The elaborate craft kit with 47 tiny pieces looks creative until someone has to help clean up the inevitable mess.
Gifts that contradict parents' values or family rules cause tension. If parents are limiting screen time and you show up with a tablet, you've created a problem. If they're teaching their child about mindful consumption and you arrive with bags of plastic toys from the dollar store, you've undermined their efforts. This doesn't mean you can't be generous. It means aligning your generosity with what actually helps the family function.
Consider storage and space limitations. Many families live in smaller homes where toy overflow becomes a real issue. One thoughtful, high-quality gift that gets regular use beats ten items that clutter closets. Parents also struggle with gifts that require batteries, extensive assembly, or ongoing purchases of supplies. Before buying that elaborate science kit, ask yourself who will help the child use it and whether parents have the time and energy for that.
The communication strategy that prevents gift disasters
The solution to holiday gift stress isn't guessing better—it's asking directly. Most parents would rather give you specific suggestions than receive gifts that don't work for their family. Try this approach: "I want to get Lily something she'll really enjoy for the holidays. What are a few things that would work well for your family right now?" This question respects parents' knowledge of their child while showing you value their input.
Some parents create wishlists or registries specifically to help gift-givers. Don't take this as a limitation on your creativity. View it as insider information that helps you succeed. If a list feels too restrictive, pick one item from the list and add a complementary gift that matches the same developmental stage or interest area. For example, if they list a particular book, you could add another book from the same series or by the same author.
Timing matters too. Reach out at least six weeks before the holidays to give yourself time to shop thoughtfully instead of panic-buying at the last minute. If you're shopping online, factor in shipping times and potential delays. Nothing creates more stress than scrambling on December 23rd to find something—anything—that seems appropriate.
Making gift-giving work for long-distance grandparents
Distance adds an extra challenge to holiday gift selection. You're not observing what captures your grandchild's attention or frustrates them. Video calls help, but they don't give you the full picture of what's happening developmentally. This is when communication with parents becomes even more critical. Schedule a call specifically to discuss gift ideas. Come prepared with questions: "What's Zane really into right now? What makes him light up? What has he outgrown recently?"
Consider subscription services or experiences that create ongoing connection. A monthly book subscription means you're part of their life throughout the year, not just during holidays. Experience gifts work well for long-distance relationships because they often include photos or videos you can enjoy together later. Some grandparents send supplies for a specific activity—art materials, baking ingredients, science experiment kits—and then schedule a video call to do the activity together.
For babies and very young children, involve parents in the gift experience through photos and videos. Ask—but don’t demand—that parents send pictures of the baby playing with your gift. This helps you see what actually engages them and refine your gift-giving for next time. It also gives parents an easy way to acknowledge your gift and stay connected with you.
The real gift grandchildren want most
Here's what most gift guides won't tell you: the best gift you can give your grandchildren isn't something you can buy at a store. Children who have strong relationships with their grandparents report higher self-esteem and better emotional well-being. Your presence, attention, and genuine interest in their lives matter more than any toy or gadget. This doesn't mean material gifts are meaningless. It means the most powerful gifts combine a thoughtful item with the relationship behind it.
Think about what you can give that creates connection. A book becomes more meaningful when you read it together during visits or video calls. A board game works better when you play it with them. Art supplies gain value when you create alongside them. The gift becomes a vehicle for relationship rather than a substitute for it.
You may also like: